Thread:AnnaElzaJ/@comment-43279580-20200906150357/@comment-30900271-20200908085516

Okay, I think that not-debunked is fine, so secret room is fine too ;) The Nattmara, well, there are many magical creatures in the universe, like the trolls or the spirits, so for me it's fine, I only wonder why it took it that long given how long Elsa was afraid... Anna waking up, well, she still sleeps too long ;)

I guess I used the wrong word, I meant that she behaves as if it was her younger sister that needs protection sometimes ;)

I know the movies are the base for everything and I didn't state otherwise ;) Of course Kamilla had to have F2 in mind when writing, the book was written to 'bridge the gap' between the movies. I think she was often on the phone with the directors and other F2 crew to keep things consistent ;) And if we look just at the movies, FoS fits well... Maybe this 'doesn't feel right' implies that Anna is confused by Elsa sleeping in another bedroom too and the rest seems okay :)

I know, we have a lot of opinions and speculations here ;) Speaking of which, I have another idea how to make things fit - first the night happened as in FoS, except Anna fell asleep again for a short moment, Iduna and Agnarr left the room thinking she'll sleep, later Anna woke up alone and confused, maybe troll's magic in her head made her forget she woke up earlier that night and her parents were there. Later things went as in AFH - she left the room confused, met mom and dad, they lied to her, later she met Elsa and Elsa pushed her away... That sleep never came would happen later as completely confused and wide awake Anna tried to wrap her mind around the situation.... What do you think?