Category talk:Musicians

Talk
Okay, I made a category titled "Musicians", and I've already added a few pages to this category. I want to get some feedback on this category to know what you guys think. Jjuser (talk) 00:18, March 15, 2015 (UTC)


 * I don't see it as a necessary category. The categorization system exists to make navigation around here easy. We already have the "Crew" category, which accounts for the musicians and the animators and such. There isn't such a large volume of crew member pages that distinguishing their role is necessary. The term is also very general ... technically both Idina Menzel and Kristen Bell can be called musicians, but I'm guessing not in the context of this category.
 * Dragonboy6491 (talk) 12:51, March 15, 2015 (UTC)


 * Hmm, that makes sense, but I was thinking that we could create a "Musicians" category to categorize the crew members who were involved with the music from Frozen. We could also include the singers from the film in this category. Then again, if we were to keep this category, it would make sense to create another category titled "Animators", and, like you said, there aren't enough crew members to begin distinguishing their roles in the film. Okay, I see your point, we can live without this category. Still, I want to see if there are any benefits to adding this category. If there aren't, then this category shall be deleted.
 * Jjuser (talk) 19:52, March 15, 2015 (UTC)


 * I still think the low number of crew member pages will outweigh any advantages this category may have. We do not want to get into the habit of "overcategorization". That said, I'll be interested to hear what others think.
 * Dragonboy6491 (talk) 14:30, March 16, 2015 (UTC)


 * Having Musicians is overdoing it...we don't want to end up like the Disney Wiki, who have categories for things like tomboys... Heimr Arnadalr (talk) 00:22, March 17, 2015 (UTC)


 * So it's settled, then? There should be no "Musicians" category due to the fact that there aren't enough crew members. Okay, good reasoning, now it's time to delete this category, I guess :P
 * Jjuser (talk) 01:14, March 17, 2015 (UTC)