Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5189655-20150205205704/@comment-5189655-20150206145740

Humphry02 wrote: I will reply in more detail later, but I am still slightly opposed to the idea. I will say that I am not completely opposed, but there are things to consider when we do it, as it may be difficult to add up just the Frozen character parts without relying on something else. I also think that, if at all, OUAT should be on one page and one page only, with everything detailed there. It is non-canon, so it does not need as much detail as Frozen itself or any other canon, which is our main purpose. I understand what it is that you're refering to, namely how the Frozen-arc jumps right into the fourth (and end of the third) season and how that could potentially leave some holes in the coherence of the storyline. This doesn't have to be a problem if it is dealt with properly and is written in a coherent-way. Consider that the end of the third season of OUAT is the start of a completely new story;

"Once upon a time, two people lost in time had finally found their way back home, but along the way brings something back to their realm which would be the beginning of a new tale."

Do you see what I'm getting at? Issues with incoherence can be dealt with if done in a proper way. Regarding the OUAT related contents being all gathered on one single article, that I believe is a question which has to be dealt with when the article(s) is being written. I believe it has to be given as many articles as is necessary (not saying it doesn't need just one page). I also think that on every character-page on this wiki (for characters which appear in OUAT) it should be mentioned if they are featured on the show.

Also, if we're only going to list canon-appearances on the character-pages then only the film, its shorts and sequels should be listed, and not OUAT or any game- or book-adaptations.