Thread:Humphry02/@comment-40163149-20200614023948/@comment-25389622-20200617154812

Hi there

Right. Ships may also be referred to using female pronouns, and obviously they are not alive. Same goes for "Mother Nature" - although that can be considered more "alive" than a ship. So perhaps it is alive in the same way that Mother Nature is, but we do not know this for sure.

Yes, the memory of her mother was selected by Ahtohallan to show to Elsa. Though I wouldn't say that the memory has been changed in any meaningful way. Iduna repeats the line to Elsa from the lullaby. The next line obviously isn't said by her, but the two are singing and so it is best not to take the scene too literally - the line serves more as exposition within the song.

I understand that as Ahtohallan being the source of Elsa's magic. It does not have to be alive for this to be the case. But then again the magic is so mysterious that it may be a bit premature to posit this. When does Agnarr say about glaciers? Besides that, just because the spirits are "as old as glaciers" does not mean that they were created by Ahtohallan itself. It may just mean that they came into existence at around the same time.

To answer the rest of your questions: No, it cannot be added to the trivia section, because it is far too conjectural. Review what you have said to see what I mean. It's fair enough on your part to take these facts and try and draw conclusions from them, but for something to be added to a page, the fact must be definitive, in that it happened and we may cite a source. So to say in the trivia, "Ahtohallan is considered alive", one must have a credible source to back this up. Although at that point I think it would be worth integrating into the main page.

Thank you for taking the time to ask.