Thread:LockAndKey989/@comment-43279580-20200930154004

he directors may have given Kamilla plot points for the sequel when writing the book and tips on characters dialogue. But that doesn’t automatically make it canon.

Good Reason:
 * 1) First is all it is not referenced at all in the sequel despite seemingly happening a month before.

Secondary Reasons: it just doesn’t match up with other extended media. Elsa and Anna went on a grand tour (together) in Across the Sea. Elsa tells Anna her worries of being a poor ruler in Phantoms of Arendelle. In a comic from the OFFICIAL Frozen magazine Elsa had nightmares for a whole week. And in literally everything else (shorts and all) Elsa abd Anna’s relationship is much better than in this book. Also it doesnt alight with Frozen Heart (which is regarded as canon): the way Anna wakes up and Anna recalling her time Frozen.
 * 1) Neither Anna nor Elsa mention it when they are alone together in her room when Elsa says “I’m afraid I’ll mess up” and Anna says “mess what up? Your doing great” not “I’m afraid I might mess up...like..you know.” And “Elsa your doing great, I mean since that one thing but we beat it together”
 * 2) Anna also doesn’t mention it to Elsa when recalling all the reasons she can take care of herself like “and saved you from my ex boyfriend” no mention of saving her or Arendelle from a giant wolf of fears.
 * 3) Secondly, but not least, the author recalls one crucial aspect wrong about their childhood. At the prologue it is stated that Anna and Elsa were already living in SEPARATE rooms at the time of the incident. When in CANON they shared a room until Elsa moved out after the incident. And when Elsa recalls last time she had a nightmare when she was 8 in her room she didn’t say “our room”, and this had to be before the incident because after that Iduna taught her a trick to get rid of her fear resulting in the Nattmara’s creation, then when Anna has the accident the wolf has moved to her head to give her nightmares.

Stupid Reason: Here Anna’s hair is “chest-nut” brown. Not strawberry blonde. Someone also pointed out that Anna knocks 5 times in the book instead of six (do you want to build a snowman). And Its said that the parents ship went down seven years ago, not six. 